Regulator's data centre inquiry draws industry response
Industry body presses for domestic evidence as rights commission probes digital infrastructure
The South African Human Rights Commission opened its formal inquiry into data centres and digital infrastructure to public submissions in May 2026, and the Internet Service Providers’ Association has already responded. ISPA, the industry body officially recognised by the Department of Communications and Digital Technologies, urges the commission to ground its assessment in domestic evidence rather than assumptions drawn from foreign markets.
The timing is pointed. Government has elevated the sector through the National Data and Cloud Policy and announced plans for state investment in cloud infrastructure, positioning data centres as strategic infrastructure for economic growth and digital transformation. That policy posture is precisely what ISPA says the inquiry should test against facts rather than imported narratives.
“Let’s establish the facts and use them to figure out an evidence-based balance between socioeconomic development and observing fundamental rights, and growth and the economy,” says Dominic Cull, ISPA’s regulatory advisor.
A central claim in the submission concerns regulatory parity. ISPA argues that data centre developers in South Africa must comply with the same environmental, planning, water, heritage, licensing and energy requirements that apply to any other infrastructure developer, and it rejects suggestions that the industry enjoys special exemptions. Many local operators, with whom the association says it engages on an ongoing basis, demonstrate corporate citizenship and environmental stewardship that go beyond what the law requires.
Meanwhile, electricity and water consumption sit at the heart of public concern about the industry’s rapid growth. ISPA concedes that data centres are energy-intensive. Its argument is that much of the information circulating in the debate relies on figures from markets such as the United States, whose energy and water conditions differ significantly from South Africa’s. It also contends that consolidating computing capacity in modern, efficient facilities is preferable to reliance on dispersed, legacy IT infrastructure.
On the electricity system itself, the submission goes further. Growing data centre investment, ISPA argues, could provide more predictable demand at a time when rising renewable generation and other factors are reshaping the country’s energy landscape. Additional industrial demand could support the economics of the electricity system and potentially moderate price increases for consumers, though the association acknowledges this depends on the broader dynamics of supply, demand and pricing. On water, it points to the commercial incentive operators have to minimise consumption and says local usage is being driven below global averages, although the submission offers no comparative figures.
Beyond resources, ISPA frames locally hosted infrastructure as a matter of national capability. Data centres within South Africa’s borders, it argues, strengthen the country’s ability to respond to cyberattacks, disinformation campaigns and economic pressure from foreign actors, and it links domestic digital infrastructure to the protection of democracy and the freedom of expression that internet access enables. The association neither owns nor operates data centres, but its members depend on them to deliver services, which it says gives the industry a direct stake in the inquiry’s outcome.
By contrast, the South African debate unfolds against an international backdrop where opposition to data centre growth has acquired political force. In the United States, Texas governor-elect Gina Hinojosa, who defeated incumbent Greg Abbott in the 3 November election, campaigned on halting approvals for new data centres until legislation protects communities, alongside commitments to end tax incentives for developers and give local communities a greater say in proposed projects. Her victory has cast uncertainty over billions of dollars in planned investment in one of the largest markets for AI infrastructure, and drew a pointed response from Elon Musk, who had backed Abbott and posted on X that “data Centers in space looking pretty appealing right now.”
Whether similar political momentum takes hold in South Africa remains to be seen. For now, the question rests with the commission and its inquiry. Cull expects a measured outcome: “South Africa has an impressive track-record of polar opposites finding the middle ground in the best interests of the country. ISPA is confident the data centre debate will be settled as reasonable South Africans find each other, as always.” ISPA advocates for an open, free and competitive internet landscape; more information is available at www.ispa.org.za.
Q&A
Which oversight body is conducting the inquiry into data centres, and when did it open to public submissions?
The South African Human Rights Commission, which opened its formal inquiry into data centres and digital infrastructure to public submissions in May 2026.
What is ISPA's central argument in its submission?
It urges the commission to ground its assessment in domestic evidence rather than assumptions drawn from foreign markets, and argues developers already comply with the same environmental, planning, water, heritage, licensing and energy requirements as other infrastructure developers.
What does ISPA say about data centres and the electricity system?
ISPA argues additional industrial demand could support the economics of the electricity system and potentially moderate price increases for consumers, though this depends on broader supply, demand and pricing dynamics.
What political developments in the United States are shaping the international backdrop?
Texas governor-elect Gina Hinojosa campaigned on halting approvals for new data centres until legislation protects communities, ending tax incentives for developers and giving local communities a greater say, drawing a response from Elon Musk on X.