South Africa’s plan to build 1,500 megawatts of new coal-fired power capacity has hit a decisive legal obstacle, after the Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed the government’s bid to revive the project. The ruling means a previous High Court judgment striking down the plan stands, and it hands the state a heavier burden if it wants to keep coal in its delivery plans.
The case, known as #CancelCoal, was brought by a coalition of environmental NGOs whose central argument was that adding new coal capacity would violate children’s constitutional right to a healthy environment. The Centre for Environmental Rights, which represented the plaintiffs, said air pollution from coal-fired power stations already kills more than 2,200 South Africans each year and causes thousands of cases of bronchitis and asthma.
At the heart of the dispute was an implementation question: whether the country’s electricity supply depends on new coal plants. The Minister of Electricity and Energy argued that additional coal capacity was necessary for energy security. The High Court rejected that reasoning, ruling against the plan on the basis that it violates the right to an environment not harmful to health and well-being.
The High Court also found that government arguments about grid stability offered by coal were not sufficient justification for the violation of constitutional rights, according to Michelle Sithole, senior associate in the pollution and climate change program at the Centre for Environmental Rights, speaking in an email to Mongabay.
When the Minister appealed that judgment, the Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, leaving the High Court decision in place. For the project itself, the effect is concrete: the plan to procure 1,500 megawatts of new coal power cannot proceed on the legal footing the government had relied upon.
Meanwhile, Sithole cautioned that the outcome does not amount to a definitive end to new coal-fired power as part of the country’s energy security policy. What it does mean, she said, is that government faces a higher standard when it seeks to justify choosing coal for electricity generation. She added that the Minister of Electricity and Energy may still take the ruling further, with the option of appealing the Supreme Court of Appeal’s decision to the South African Constitutional Court.
For the groups behind the litigation, the decision is a check on how the state plans and delivers its electricity, and on what costs that delivery is allowed to carry. “Our and our clients’ position has been that there are cheaper, cleaner and more sustainable sources of energy,” Sithole said. “Energy security should not come at the expense of people’s lives, health and well-being. We would like government’s electricity plans to reflect that.”
The practical question now is whether the government reworks its procurement approach around alternatives, or tests the appellate ruling at the Constitutional Court. Either way, any future attempt to bring new coal capacity online must clear a higher constitutional bar than the one the High Court found wanting. More detail on the ruling is available via Mongabay: https://news.mongabay.com/short-article/south-african-court-dismisses-appeal-over-planned-coal-fired-power-plants/